We consider ourselves among the Halloween Makeup experts, but even we have to admit that these Reddit users have our skills beat. Some of these real-girl makeup creations have us cringing in terror (especially the demented clown), and it’s all done with eye shadows, body paint, false lashes, and incredible talent. This is the creepiest makeup artistry we’ve ever seen, but we’re already getting renewed inspiration for our costume this year.
1: Enraged Elsa
2: Siamese Twins
3: All-Seeing Eyes
4: Scaly Seawoman
5: Opulent Owl
6: Elf Eyes
7: Hungry Hellion
8: Evil Eyes
9: Comical Crying
